The Destruction of World heritage

 

 

UNESCO was created to protect World Heritage sites, in order to “promote peace and harmony within nations” (lecture). Its intriguing to discover that these heritage sites are also destroyed, to inflict some type of purpose. The destruction of heritage sites tends to be a product of  wars between nations, and political contradictions. Destroying heritage sites can be used as a great weapon because “ even a single act of destruction can come to be known and have repercussions throughout the world.”(Viego-Rose 54)

images

 

The Buddhas of Bamiyan were one of the heritage sites to be the victims of destruction. The Buddhas of Bamiyan are statues located in the Bamiyan Valley, in Afghanistan. Archeologist  believe the statues were establish by the Buddhist monks. They were carve into the mountain around the 6th century.  There were numerous tries to destroy the statues. Aurangzeb, a Mughal emperor, attempted to destroy the statues by using heavy artillery. The statues were, sadly, eventually destroyed by the Taliban on March 2001.

 

“Heritage itself contains contradictions and has to manage conflicting needs. Heritage sites represent a conglomerate of symbols and narratives…,”(Viego-Rose 55) which is why the Taliban found it necessary to dispose of the statues. They thought it would be a reasonable and affective way to send a message. This helps us acknowledge the fact that people can use our heritage against us. Even though the destruction of the Buddhas was a great lost, in some way, it brought people together to reconstruct the statues. It also made the intangible heritage of the site stronger.

 

Warsaw-Market-Square

Something extraordinary with the destruction of world heritage sites is, that at times, when a site is purposely destroyed the intangible heritage is still there. The intangible heritage can even be made stronger because of the destruction that took place there. The Market Place at Warsaw was destroyed by the German Army, during World War Two (lecture). Even though Warsaw was completely destroyed, it was rebuilt, and still allowed to become a world heritage site. The reason for this, could be, because of the intangible heritage it developed because of how it was affected by World War Two. “War not only destroys heritage, it transforms, adds new meaning, and even engenders new heritage.”(Viego-Rose 57) 

 

Heritage has been the subject of destruction, due to wars and political clash. The attempts to destroy material heritage, have been most of the time successful. Intangible heritage, on the other hand, is nearly impossible to destroy. Even if the material form of heritage is destroyed, the intangible form is still there, and at times made stronger. The destruction of world heritage represents the struggle to preserve these sites. It also conveys the notion that intangible heritage is stronger, and more reliable than tangible heritage.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Destruction of World heritage

  1. mbrooks8 says:

    I like this post for it’s positive reinforcing despite the apparent setbacks caused by destruction. Even though something may have a directly negative effect, it may also have an indirect positive effect. Great examples as well, because many people can relate in their knowledge of the Taliban and World War Two’s destruction.

  2. jortega95 says:

    I like that you brought up the fact that a lot of communities primarily emphasize their heritage through aspects of intangible heritage. It is important to note that it is not the site that defines a heritage, but rather the connection people hold with the site. The Buddha statues were a representation of the heritage, but foundation of the actual heritage itself was established before that. The values, traditions, practices, etc. where all important before the construction of the statues and continued to be exercised after the destruction.

  3. I really enjoyed your post and I also agree that war can both damage and create heritage. War can cause the destruction of a World Heritage site but it can also create Heritage for the people that are involved in the site. An example of a war created heritage could be Pearl Harbor in Honolulu. Because of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor, the US joined in World War II and today there are memorials and museums for this site that hundreds of tourists visit throughout the year.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s